Suite101

Asthma And Scuba Diving

The Risks Associated With An Asthmatic On A Scuba Dive

© Bruce Iliff

Nov 1, 2008
Scuba Diving With Asthma Has Risks, Bruce ILIFF
Scuba diving with asthma is a debate that has raged in the scuba and medical communities since Jacques Cousteau invented the first aqua-lung.

Some scuba divers go diving with asthma, sneaking the fact through their dive medical exam. Others have dived with asthma and have died from barotrauma or a burst lung.

What is Asthma?

Asthma occurs when the small airways in the lungs become blocked, due to inflammation or a build-up of mucous. This leads to difficulty breathing, wheezing, pains in the chest and shortness of breath.

An asthma attack can be caused by environmental changes, such as breathing cool, dry air, or pollens in the air; and can also be triggered by stress and anxiety.

The Australian Lung Foundation states that about 1 in 10 adults in Australia have asthma. And 1 in 5 children.

Asthma is usually controlled by the use of medications delivered in a “puffer.”

Risk Of Asthma When Scuba Diving

The risk for a scuba diver is when an asthma attack occurs underwater. The small airways can close up, trapping air in the lungs; and a diver can’t get relief by using their asthma puffer underwater.

The trapped air expands when the diver ascends, and if the air can’t get out of the lungs due to the inflammation or mucous build-up from the asthma attack, then the only way to relieve this pressure is to burst the lung.

This leads to other problems, that don’t need to be covered here, except to say that a scuba diver with a burst lung is in the “scuba death zone.”

Asthma Attacks Triggered By Scuba Diving

The following are a few ways in which asthma may be triggered by scuba diving.

  • Dry air

The compressed air in a scuba tank has been dried when the tank is filled.

  • Cool air

When air moves from the higher pressure in the tank to the lower pressure at the regulator, the air cools.

  • Stress and anxiety

Most people are under some stress when scuba diving. That is, there is more stress underwater than when talking about the dive when safely on dry land.

  • Environmental

Accidentally breathing salt or fresh water particles can also trigger an asthma attack

Can An Asthmatic Scuba Dive?

There is no clear agreement of opinion on whether an asthmatic should dive or not. Obviously, if the diver is showing symptoms of asthma they shouldn’t dive; the risk is too great.

The risk is when a diver with history of asthma, but doesn’t exhibit symptoms when entering the water, has an asthma attack underwater.

General opinion seems to be that an asthmatic can dive if the following are met:

  • no symptoms of asthma in the past five years
  • no use of anti-asthma medication in the past five years
  • successful completion of a diving medical, including breathing tests
  • the diver is aware of the risks when diving with asthma.

Can An Asthmatic Dive Only At Shallow Depths?

An asthmatic should not take the approach, “I’ll just stay in shallow water.” This is not a solution, as the majority of pressure change occurs in the first ten metres. That is, the pressure change between the surface and ten metres deep is 100%; while the pressure change between 20 meters and 10 metres is only 50%.

It is this pressure change that can burst a lung if the asthma attack prevents the air in the lungs from being released on ascent.

Disclaimer

The information in this article is intended as a guide only. It is not an authoritative statement. Scuba divers with asthma should consult their medical specialist for specific medical advice. The author has no liability for the use or misuse of the information contained in this article.


The copyright of the article Asthma And Scuba Diving in Scuba Diving is owned by Bruce Iliff. Permission to republish Asthma And Scuba Diving in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.


Scuba Diving With Asthma Has Risks, Bruce ILIFF
       


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo

Comments
Mar 1, 2009 1:13 PM
Guest :
Your approach is cautious and is to be commended. It should be pointed out that current symptoms of asthma are absolutely irrelevant. There can be local and global changes in the flow of air to the lung that are totally tranparent to the individual and can be present before the dive commences, or as you point out become manifest after the dive has begun. Very shallow water with air under pressure can result in lung damage underwater which is a distinclty bad thing to have happen under water.

In the end the ONLY safe dive is the one that you did not do.

L M Garges, M.D. Undersea Meical Officer, USN (Ret)
1 Comment: